Skip to content

Applying the criteria of European market standards for seafood products to concrete cases – Operability study and methodological developments

A collaboration between Sayari and students from Ecole polytechnique on fisheries impact on biodiversity

Reading time: 6 min

Once again this year (2022-2023), we have supported students from the Ecole Polytechnique in their joint scientific project. Objective: to establish a biodiversity impact indicator for fishery products. The starting point was STECF publications on sustainability criteria for fish products. The STECF (Scientific, Technical and Economic Committee for Fisheries) is the European Commission’s scientific body for fisheries. It has proposed (qualitative) criteria to assess this sustainability in 2020 [1], into (quantitative) indicators to objectify these criteria in 2022 [2]. This project has enabled us to operationalize these sustainable fishing criteria by comparing them with available data.

This project enabled the engineering students to become familiar with the scientific research approach: literature review, method development, data collection, application to case studies, critical analysis, writing and scientific popularization. Supervised by Grégoire and Aurore, they followed a rigorous timetable (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Project schedule and introduction of team members. From left to right: Flore Baize-Roch, Aymeric Bes-de-Berc, Ines Fonquernie, Anaïs Bourissou, Ambre Price; Grégoire Gaillet, Aurore Wermeille.

The aim was to compare methods for assessing sustainable fishing criteria with data available directly on the products: species fished, fishing area and fishing technique.

Their work led to:

  1. Propose evaluation methods for the majority of criteria;
  2. Apply them to case studies, comparing them with expected sustainability results from the literature;
  3. Develop a critical perspective on the relevance and feasibility of indicators.

5 of the 8 STECF environmental indicators were studied in terms of their impact on biodiversity; they were tested on 17 case studies (Figure 2).

Figure 2. Qualitative sustainability criteria proposed by STECF (left) and quantitative indicators studied as part of the project (right). The quantitative indicator « Impact on ETP species » is considered important, but was not studied as part of this project, pending the method currently being developed by the STECF. * ETP = Endangered, Threatened, and Protected species.

Some methodological aspects:

For the « Fishing pressure » indicator, an alternative method to the STECF method[1] has been developed. It systematically takes into account stock biomass and mortality, as well as their respective stabilities. This method is more discriminating than the initial method (CSTEP), providing a better distinction between the impact of fishing pressure on different products.

The STECF method for the « Impact on the seabed » indicator was followed: it is applicable to all products. Application to the case studies shows that this method mainly gives extreme scores: pelagic fish score mostly A, while groundfish score mostly E, with few nuances.

A method is currently being developed by the STECF for the « Impact on ETP (Endangered, Threatened and Protected) species » indicator. It has therefore not been studied as part of this project.

To assess the « Discards and by-catches » indicator, an initial method has been developed. It enables the characteristics of fishing gear to be taken into account: bottom vs. pelagic gear, active vs.

In order to assess the « Impact on the food web » indicator, a method has been developed. It takes into account the trophic level of the species and the relative biomass of the stock fished, two important elements for measuring the complexity of marine ecosystems. However, there is still room for improvement: other criteria will have to be included at a later date, to take into account non-trophic relationships and the role of keystone species.

A turnkey method is proposed for assessing the performance of Regional Fisheries Management Organizations (RFMOs) under the « Fisheries management » indicator. It takes into account ecological, governance and transparency criteria. Regional and specific RFMOs are evaluated and ranked in the Table 1.

Table 1. Classification of Regional Fisheries Management Organizations according to the indicator developed for this project. Geographically defined organizations (red) are distinguished from organizations defined by the species they study (migratory species – yellow). The 4 oceans are distinguished (shades of blue).

« Carbon footprint » and « Waste and pollution » indicators are covered by Life Cycle Assessment. They were therefore not studied as part of this project.

Figure 3. Ranking and weighting of individual criteria to obtain the aggregated indicator.

Data collection, a major challenge for the project:

  • Scientific data can be broken down into several categories: i) fixed biological data on species and information on ecosystems and RFMOs, and ii) temporal and spatial data on stock status and fishing pressure. These data can be complex to collect, and Sayari’s expertise has enabled us to cross-reference the various databases, assess their relevance and determine the appropriate proxies.
  • Product data {species – area – gear} may be insufficient to identify the stock, or different criteria depending on the precision of the information. We have worked on collecting detailed information in order to make the most accurate possible assessment.

The results obtained enable us to classify the products tested from the most to the least virtuous (Table 2).

Table 2. Ratings for the different product scenarios tested. Products are ranked from most to least virtuous. NB: The score could not be obtained for two scenarios {European lobster (Homarus gammarus) – East Irish Sea – Trap} and {Scallop (Pecten maximus) – Channel – Bay of Saint-Brieuc – Dive fishing} because these two species are detritus feeders and have no trophic level.

Key project messages

  • Our cooperation with the academic world is bearing fruit: for the students, who have developed new skills and knowledge and have been praised for the quality of their work! But also, for the application of scientific knowledge, enabling us to offer decision-makers operational methods for environmental impact assessment.
  • Three indicators have been finalized:
    • The « Fishing pressure » and « Seabed impact » indicators with CSTEP methods compared with the methods used in this project;
    • The « Fisheries Management » indicator with the method developed in this project, a turnkey solution for evaluating organisations.
  • Two indicators have been the subject of initial scientific development. Further development is required to make them operational.
  • The challenge of combining scientific data and product data (given by the fish supplier) is a major one, and Sayari’s expertise and resources enable us to link them effectively for a pertinent assessment of the environmental impact of fishing.

[1] STECF, « Scientific, Technical and Economic Committee for Fisheries (STECF) – Criteria and indicators to incorporate sustainability aspects for seafood products in the marketing standards under the Common Market Organisation (STECF-20-05) », 2020.

[2] STECF, « Scientific, Technical and Economic Committee for Fisheries (STECF) – Validation of selected sustainability indicators and underlying methodologies for the revision of the EU marketing standards for fisheries products (STECF-22-12) », 2022.

We offer solutions adapted to your ambitions and resources

Would you like to find out about our latest studies or discover our new projects? Follow us on LinkedIn

  Member of the European PEF (Product Environmental Footprint) Technical Advisory Board

  Member of the French ADEME environmental labelling working group

COMPANY NAME
Sayari –Sayari whose head office is located 6 rue Carnot, 78212 Saint-Germain en Laye, France.

RESPONSIBLE FOR PUBLICATION
Editorial Manager: Ms. Anne-Claire Asselin
Data protection officer: Ms. Anne-Claire Asselin

NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE HOST
In accordance with the French law n ° 2004-575 of June 21, 2004 for the confidence in the digital economy, we inform you that the website « marine-biodiversity-footprint.com/ » is the property of Sayari.
Website “https://sayari.co/” was designed by the company ideephare.
“marine-biodiversity-footprint.com” website is hosted on the IT equipment of company “1 & 1 IONOS SARL” whose head office is located: 7 place de la Gare, 57201 SARREGUEMINES– France.
“Sayari.co” site is governed by French law; visitors accessing from abroad must ensure compliance with French and European laws.

DISCHARGE OF RESPONSIBILITY
Ms. Anne-Claire Asselin is only bound by a simple obligation of means concerning the information that is made available to people who access the website « www.marine-biodiversity-footprint.com »
Even though we have taken all steps to ensure the reliability of the information contained on this website, Ms. Anne-Claire Asselin cannot be held responsible for errors, omissions, or for results that could be obtained by using this information. In particular, the use of hypertext links can lead your consultation of our site to other servers, over which Sayari has no control. Sayari’s website is normally accessible 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. In the event of force majeure, computer difficulties, difficulties linked to structure of telecommunications networks or technical difficulties, for reasons of maintenance- without this list being exhaustive-, access to all or part of the site may be suspended or deleted by simple decision of Sayari. For maintenance reasons, and / or for any other decision by the Sayari company, access to website may be interrupted. Our website is subject to change and development without notification of any kind.

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
This site is subject to the legislation on copyright and literary and artistic property rights. All intellectual property rights, including trademark rights, copyrights, texts, illustrations, photos or logos are the property of Sayari. The elements of this site may not be used, modified altered or reproduced in whole or in part or be subject of any exploitation. Reproductions, on paper or computer support of all or part of the site, are authorized provided that they are strictly reserved for personal use, excluding any use for advertising and / or commercial purposes, and that they comply with provisions of article L122-5 of the Intellectual Property Code and that none of the warnings concerning the ownership of the site and these elements are erased. With the exception of the above provisions, any reproduction, representation, use or modification, by any process whatsoever and on any medium whatsoever, of all or part of the pages of the site, without having obtained the prior authorization of Sayari is strictly prohibited.
You will also refrain from entering data on the website “https://sayari.co/” which would modify or which could modify content or appearance of the data, the presentation or the organization of the site. or works appearing on the TRANSITION website and by any means whatsoever.

PERSONAL DATA
Sayari collects information from visitors to the website « www.marine-biodiversity-footprint.com » by means of questionnaires on the website. This information is used to respond to your requests for information. It is not stored in computer files, nor is it sold or exchanged.

The personal information that is collected is limited to that which is necessary to contact you (first name, last name, e-mail, company, telephone, address, postal code, city, country). They are not kept within the framework of this form.

In accordance with the provisions of Articles 38 and following of Law 78-17 of January 6, 1978, and the RGPD (Regulation of the Protection of Personal Data) Regulation 2016/679 of April 27, 2016, you have at any time a right of access, communication, rectification, updating and deletion of personal data concerning you. To exercise any of these rights, you can send a request by mail to the following address
Sayari – Mrs Anne Claire Asselin – 6 rue Carnot – 78112 Saint-Germain en Laye, France or by email to the address: contact@sayari.co

COOKIES
This website uses cookies which do not allow to identify you personally (name-address). Cookies are computer files which are installed on your computer via your browser and which contain information about your navigation when you visit the pages of the site.
These cookies can be permanent or session specific. We use cookies for tracking and statistical purposes to understand your expectations and your interest in our products. They also allow us to improve functioning and performance of navigation on our site.
Setting of your Internet browser allows you to be informed of the presence of cookies and to block these cookies. You can view cookies with most text editors or word processing programs. The list below explains how to display cookies in different browsers. If you use another browser, see the cookie information specific to that browser. If you are using a mobile phone, refer to its user manual for more information.
• Firefox : https://support.mozilla.org/cookies
• Chrome :https://support.google.com/cookies
• Internet Explorer 8-11: https://windows.microsoft.com/explorer/cookies
• Microsoft Edge : https://www.privacy.microsoft/edge
• Opera : http://www.opera.com/help
Disabling cookies may limit your access to all or part of the website or other sites.
This site uses Google Analytics, which allows us to determine which pages are most viewed by Internet users and to improve our content, as well as to count the number of visitors and analyze the way in which Internet users navigate within this site. Google Analytics is a website analysis service offered by Google Inc. The data generated by cookies regarding your use of the site (including your IP address). Google will not associate your IP address with any other data held by Google. For more information on Google Analytics: https://support.google.com/analytics and https://www.google.fr/intl/fr/policies/privacy/.
Note also that we have installed on our site an « anonymized » version of Google analytics which does not allow Google to keep data which could be qualified as personal.
You can deactivate the use of cookies by selecting the appropriate settings on your browser. However, such deactivation could prevent the use of some features of this site.
This site may provide access to or embed videos, photos and music from sites such as YouTube. By visiting a page that contains integrated content from one of these sites, cookies from these sites may be placed on your browser or on your computer’s hard drive. For more information on YouTube, you can visit https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/171780. You can deactivate the use of cookies by selecting the appropriate settings on your browser. However, such deactivation could prevent the use of certain features of this site.

APPLICABLE RIGHT
These terms and conditions are subject to the law of Sayari. In the event of a dispute as to their interpretation, application or execution, the French courts will have sole jurisdiction.

COOKIES
By using this site, you accept the use of anonymous cookies for the purpose of statistical audience measurement – See above paragraph “Cookies”

Back To Top